Apple has urged a federal judge in New Jersey to dismiss an antitrust lawsuit brought by the U.S. Justice Department and multiple states. The company contends that the allegations are speculative and fail to demonstrate monopoly dominance. Apple previously filed a motion to dismiss the case, according to Bloomberg.
Allegations Against Apple
Filed in March, the lawsuit accuses Apple of violating antitrust laws by restricting third-party access to certain hardware and software features on its devices. Attorneys general from 19 states and the District of Columbia allege that Apple leveraged its monopoly over app distribution and iPhone features to suppress innovations that might encourage users to switch to other devices or integrate them with iPhones.
Specific allegations include degrading the quality of messaging between iPhones and Android devices and limiting the functionality of third-party smartwatches when paired with iPhones. The plaintiffs argue that these practices stifle competition and harm consumer choice.
Apple’s Defense
Apple’s legal team has pushed back, asserting that the lawsuit provides no substantive evidence of monopoly power or harm to consumers, notes NIX Solutions. They also argue that the company has the legal right to choose its business partners and is not obligated to enhance opportunities for its competitors.
After hearing arguments, U.S. District Judge Julien Xavier Neals announced plans to decide on Apple’s motion to dismiss by January 2025.
While the case progresses, we’ll keep you updated on developments as more details emerge.